By: Judd Spicer, Contributor, Golf Business
.
Dealing with problematic members and difficult guests typically ranks as a top daily challenge for course owners and operators. And yet, whether such omnipresent beefs have meat or otherwise, dealing with conflict requires constant patience, time and open ears.
"Active listening is at the top of the list; really trying to understand what the person is trying to say, without an interruption and without jumping into defense mode," says Anna Agafonova, a practitioner with the Sports Conflict Institute. "People don't want to be told that they’re wrong, even if they are wrong. People want to be heard, and they want to feel understood."
Across both public and private course cultures, the dollars may change but the issues don't much deviate.
"Conflict is conflict," Agafonova continues. "The situations may not be exactly the same, but the tools to resolution are similar; doesn’t matter where somebody falls in the tax bracket."
As with many if not most retail businesses (and golf, at day's end, is very much that), the pangs of a vocal minority have a way of out-sounding the satisfied masses. Such arduous voices, burdensome though they may well be, shouldn't be fast relegated to the inbox's Trash folder.
"Normally, what I find (in private club golf), is that the most difficult members are also the most invested ones; they have a strong psychological ownership behind their actions," Agafonova says. "Sometimes, course owners or operators tend to view these people as problematic; but, those that complain the most actually tend to be the most loyal. So, it's important to approach (conflict) from the perspective of seeing a loyal client or member who wants to see a change, instead of dismissing them as somebody who doesn't care about the club or course."
Conflict's road to amenable solution often finds encumbrance because of path, not destination.
"There can be a fear of process. But people tend to agree to an outcome if they're involved in that process," Agafonova explains. "If people are just told how something is done, they're much more likely to argue; but, if a conclusion is reached together then, psychologically, there's already this involvement on outcome. Handling fear of process is more important than winning the outcome, and having people be part of the process goes such a long way."
From Soldiers to Generals
While conflicts which arise at golf properties will never be wholly identical, a regular roster of schisms are certain to confront most clubs and courses. Whether such discord occurs between member-to-member, member/customer-to-staff or customer/client-to-brass, issues such as pace of play, overserving, noise, inappropriate advances, gambling, rules violations or seemingly miniscule country club dissents or disputes are all sure to find an owner's or operator's desk soon or later.
Whatever the day's beef may bring, or whatever the stature of one's golf property, having the troops properly aligned would seem a uniform strategy in approaching conflict resolution.
"I always advocate for front-line staff empowerment, and teaching staff how to resolve small matters," says Agafonova. "Staff need to be equipped with enough information, training and decision-making autonomy to not only be able to provide good customer service, but also to understand the psychology behind conflict. At the end of the day, players or members are mostly interacting with the front-line staff, so, an investment into your team that's on-the-ground is crucial."
Such an investment involves empowering staff via assurance and backing.
"Having a clear escalation path to management is so important, and that means knowing which issues get escalated and which ones don't," Agafonova continues. "Decision-making autonomy for staff comes with confidence and trust. For an employee, they should be in a position to make decisions knowing they have the full backing and support of management. What we see a lot is that people hesitate, because they want to know they have the support of their team, meaning that bond between management and front-line staff is super crucial."
While sources and courses concur that loading-up staff with copious amounts of literature or manuals is neither en vogue nor effective for dealing with conflict, clearly explained club policies, directives and chain-of-command do prove highly impactful.
"The staff reports to me, and me alone," says Mike Kelly, CEO and general manager at The Reserve Club in Indian Wells, Calif. "If they're reporting to boards or committees or members, it's the same old scenario of: If everybody's in charge, then nobody's in charge. This needs to be established from Day 1, and the way to do that is to go to your staff and ensure that they understand that members are going to come to them and give them direction and either want them to do something, to discipline them or to try and get information."
A sound and stated organizational structure can ensure that conflicts effectively and efficiently move up the chain-of-command.
"If something is policy-related or culture-related," says Kelly, "the staff needs to approach it with, 'That's a really interesting thought, and I appreciate that; I'm going to approach the general manager for the best approach to take and he or she will get back to you.' It's the GM's job to establish that."
Stated policies require a strong captain.
"There are some GMs out there who are more concerned with keeping their job than doing their job," adds Kelly. "If you go into this line of work as a GM trying to please everybody, you're doing everybody, including yourself, a disservice, and you're not going to manage the club – the club is going to manage you. GMs can't just go along to get along; that's where you run into problems."
Demonstrated procedures need to be concisely communicated to front-line employees.
"Having a firm customer service policy and going over that with staff, and letting them know not to deviate from the strategy, is the first level of importance," says Gaylord Schaap, general manager of public-access Northwood Golf Club in Monte Rio, Calif. "You need to let the customer know that you believe in your staff and that they're doing things the right way. Then there's getting to the root of the problem and getting to some compromising suggestions about how I can help resolve the issue so that the customer leaves without having a negative experience."
Echoes Kelly:
"What I've done on a regular basis with every new hire, is explain clearly to them what my role is and how I would approach issues (of conflict) within our organizational structure. My employees know I have their backs. I let them know that under no circumstances will I tolerate them being disrespected in any way and that, if they are, it's my job to deal with that."
The chain's first links are oftentimes the initial face of compliment, conflict and continuity.
"Customer relations are, of course, so important," adds Schaap. "And one of the frustrations of being the manager is that sometimes you're separated from direct contact with customers; so, you depend on your staff doing things the way you want them to do it. And that can be hard, because some people sort of have the 'regression to the norm,' where you can tell them all you want, but if they've been (working) there a long time, they just do what they think works."
A proactive approach to resolving complaints or conflict shouldn't worm up the totem.
"There are situations which move up the chain from staff and involve me reaching out to the upset guest," says Chris Caballero director of golf at member/public-access PGA West's Tournament Clubhouse in La Quinta, Calif. "Which is great, because, now they know the problem is on our radar and that we're taking the issue seriously."
Such proactivity can achieve conflict resolution via a chain's link-to-link strategy.
"If a problem gets to direct confrontation, we try to use two or three different folks," explains Schaap. "If the marshal can't resolve the problem, then they'll see if an associate can be of better help to a customer; that way, we can find out that it's not just a personality conflict, but a player who just doesn't seem to want to follow the rules."
When a conflict does elevate to the managerial rung, meeting aggression with aggression does not make a solution.
"You always gotta' go with the kid gloves; the worst way to go is to be defensive," Caballero says. "I'd never meet a customer with aggression, even if I know they're wrong and I'm right. You've just got to hear out the complaint and know that this person is angry for a reason, whether it's a good reason or not."
Ensuring that problems are addressed with discretion proves an approach which can navigate a trickle-down effect.
"What I don't do is have these conversations in front of other guests," adds Caballero. "The last thing I want is somebody checking in for the day thinking that there's a bunch of problems on the golf course. So, I just ask people in this circumstance if we can step aside and have a quiet conversation with just the two of us."
Private clubs require their own degree of discretion.
"When I have a problem with a member and it requires a level of discipline, I'm going to go to the Board and let them know I'm coming to them with a disciplinary action," explains Kelly, "but I'm not going to tell them who the member in question is. At first, that was not received well; but, their judgement can't be swayed by personal issues or personal relationships. It has to be objective."
Pre-Trouble
Many issues can be resolved before they ever begin.
"A lot of people we deal with in our business, they tend to solve conflict after something has already happened," Agafonova says. "My advice is to design systems before a crisis; once a crisis hits – that's it, and there's little room to pivot."
Knowing one's club means knowing one's members.
"You have to have a very solid relationship with the membership; a GM cannot manage a club for the office as a desk jockey," says Kelly. "Knowing the members is knowing all the different personalities, and how to approach each one, to understand who they are and what makes them tick. That gives a leg up on approaching these (conflict) situations."
Proactive positives have a way of silencing negatives.
"Golf has a fortunate position, because people are coming to have a good time," says Schaap. "People get out of the car, they're in a good mood and you want to keep them in that good mood. So, it's important to have the staff reinforce that good feeling and meet expectations. If you can keep that positive going, there's less chance of experiencing the negative."
High volume locales can find pre-conflict resolve with high volume communication.
"With the amount of play that comes through here, between the expectations of memberships, outside play, people who are coming here for the first time and it looks like Disneyland, there's something which comes up almost every day that's different than the day before," Caballero says. "So, it all comes down to communication. Say, for pace, it might involve explaining that we have every tee time booked between 6:45 until 3:45; that gives a guest a bit better understanding of why it might be a five-hour pace."
For clubs, clearly-drawn lines and boundaries can help eschew problems and conflicts before they find opportunity to arise.
"Members . . . we work for them. We are friendly, but we are not their peers," states Kelly. "And there's an obligation to keep that line and always remain within those boundaries. And that's not just for the GM, it applies to the staff as well. It can be a slippery slope, but any place I've ever worked, there have been employees which go, say, to dinners or concerts with members, and, when I got here, I told them, 'That stops right now.' When they ask why, I explain that with that friendship comes favors that no one else gets; and, secondly, when there's alcohol involved, people will say or do things that will not represent the club well."
While "conflict," by definition, owns a negative tenor, the actual process of conflict resolution can still result in positives for a course or club.
If even amid teeth grinding, course brass need to recognize the value of a complaint.
"For owners and operators, if people didn't complain, they'd never know what's wrong with their business," Agafonova concludes. "But conflict is good; conflict allows you to grow, develop different skill sets, improve your business and overcome obstacles; conflict means that the organization is alive. We all strive for no conflict, but having it is just not the reality."
.